The ball is in the field of the government

09/05/2008 Armine AVETYAN

The first President of Armenia Levon Ter-Petrosyan stated during his last week Congress that he finds it expedient to name the movement headed by him Armenian National Congress. He said it is just a suggestion for the political forces which participate in the movement to discuss. He said the political forces which will be members of the Congress will maintain their independence, structure and possibility of independent political activities. However, the first president did not rule out that in future the movement may grow into one centralized political unit. The Armenian authorities are continuing their post-election crackdown on the opposition contrary to their pledges to comply with a recent resolution adopted by the Council of Europe Parliamentary Assembly (PACE), a spokesman for opposition leader Levon Ter-Petrosyan said on Monday. Arman Musinyan said the authorities are not only keeping more than 100 opposition leaders and activists in jail but are continuing nationwide detentions of other, less known Ter-Petrosyan supporters. “We see no signs that the authorities are really addressing the problem,” he said. According to the Office of the Prosecutor-General, 89 persons are currently under arrest pending trial on charges mostly stemming from the March 1 clashes in Yerevan between security forces and opposition supporters demanding a re-run of the February 19 presidential election. Fifteen others have already been tried and convicted, virtually all of them for allegedly committing vote irregularities and resisting police during the break-up of Ter-Petrosyan’s non-stop protest in Yerevan’s Liberty Square which preceded the deadly clashes. Four of them were handed suspended jail terms after pleading guilty to the accusations, while the others protested their innocence and will have to serve their sentences in prison. The most severe punishment was given to Harutiun Urutyan, chief of Ter-Petrosyan’s election campaign office in the northwestern town of Maralik. He was convicted of obstructing the work of a local election commission and sentenced to seven years’ imprisonment. Individuals found guilty of more grave crimes in Armenia routinely get lighter sentences, especially if they did not fall foul of the government. For example, Armen Keshishyan, the former mayor of Nor Hajn, a small town 15 kilometers north of Yerevan, was sentenced to only three and a half years in prison for shooting and killing a man in broad daylight in September 2005. Keshishyan was a member of the governing Republican Party of Armenia. The Armenian government insists that none of the jailed Ter-Petrosyan loyalists was arrested and prosecuted for political reasons. Still, it has pledged to meet key demands contained in the PACE resolution adopted on April 17. One of them is “the urgent release of the persons detained on seemingly artificial and politically motivated charges.” President Serzh Sargsyan formed late last month a working group tasked with ensuring Yerevan’s compliance with the resolution. The group is headed by the chief of the presidential staff, Hovik Abrahamyan, and compromises senior law-enforcement officials and members of the Armenian delegation at the PACE. Among those lawmakers is Raffi Hovannisian, the leader of the opposition the Heritage party. Hovannisian has informed Sargsyan that he will not be able to attend the group’s meetings because of a busy travel schedule and proposed that another Heritage parliamentarian, Stepan Safaryan, be appointed in his place. The Armenian president and his four-party governing coalition rejected the proposal. Armen Rustamyan, chairman of the parliament committee on foreign relations, criticized Hovannisian’s stance on the issue on Monday. “Why is it that when it comes to real work we start looking for replacements and ways to wriggle out of it,” Rustamyan said. “This is unacceptable.” According to Avet Adonts, another pro-government Armenian member of the PACE, the working group will discuss the issue of opposition detainees at its next meeting scheduled for Wednesday. “A representative of the Office of the Prosecutor-General will present detailed information about those cases,” he said. Only two senior opposition figures, Suren Sureniants and Yerjanik Abgaryan, have been released on bail so far. Other prominent oppositionists such as Aleksandr Arzumanyan, Ter-Petrosyan’s national campaign manager, have had their pre-trial detentions prolonged by courts even after the PACE resolution. “They continue to prolong pre-trial arrests,” complained Musinyan. “This despite the fact that no investigative activities are being done with regard to the overwhelming majority of our political prisoners. In essence, the criminal cases against them are not being investigated, which only shows that those cases are fabricated.” “The regime seems in no mood to meet the PACE demands. Its assurances to the contrary are just a gimmick,” said Ruzan Khachatryan, a spokeswoman for the People’s Party of Armenia (PPA), one of two dozen opposition groups aligned to Ter-Petrosyan. Both Khachatryan and Musinyan claimed that police continue to round up and bully opposition activists across Armenia to make sure that they do not attend further anti-government protests in Yerevan. Musinyan said as recently as on April 29 an opposition supporter in the southern town of Artashat was detained and beaten by the local police to give incriminating testimony against a resident of a nearby village also sympathetic to Ter-Petrosyan. Four other opposition activists were reportedly taken to the police headquarters of Yerevan’s Malatia-Sebastia district on Saturday morning and set free at night. Anahit Bakhshyan, a parliament deputy from the Heritage, said she visited the police station and was told by the deputy chief of the district police that the four men are being questioned in connection with their participation in the March 1 unrest. Bakhshyan suggested that the real purpose of the interrogations was to extract incriminating testimony against Hakob Hakobyan, a local opposition parliamentarian arrested on charges of organizing “mass riots” as part of a coup plot allegedly hatched by Ter-Petrosyan. Hakobyan, who also heads an association of Armenian veterans of the war in Nagorno-Karabakh, began a hunger strike on April 28 in protest against his prosecution. According to his lawyer, he has decided to end the strike on Tuesday. In its resolution, the PACE also demanded that the authorities in Yerevan repeal recently enacted legal amendments that allow them to ban opposition rallies practically at will. The Venice Commission, another Council of Europe body, said the authorities have agreed to “repeal or change the amendments” and will draft corresponding changes in the law soon. Armenian officials have said the government also accepts in principle the PACE’s calls for the launch of an “independent, transparent and credible inquiry” into the March 1 violence. Some of them have suggested that it be conducted by an ad hoc parliament commission. Musinyan claimed that the government is “terrified” by the prospect of such an inquiry. “If they allow an independent investigation, all criminal cases will collapse,” he said. “We see the logically opposite process. Till now and even a day before yesterday some new people were arrested. All this brings us to the conclusion that although the government calls for a dialog meanwhile it does everything to fail it. We have always said that we are willing to start a dialog with the government and as they say the ball is in the field of the government,” said R. Khachatryan. “The PACE requirements must be fulfilled and in order to start a dialog at least all the political prisoners must be released,” said Sureniants.